Open standard · Version 1.1 · 2026-11-15
The Named-Signer Standard
When an AI drafts clinical work that someone will rely on, a named, licensed person signs it, revises it or declines it before it is relied on, and the decision is recorded so anyone holding the document can check it.
You may copy and adapt it under CC BY 4.0, including for policy, contracts and procurement. Cite it as: Named-Signer Standard, Version 1.1, 2026-11-15. harnesshealth.ai/standard.
Terms
- Clinical work
- A note, letter, summary, order, code or coverage decision about one identified person’s care.
- Drafting system
- The AI model, or the software around it, that produced the draft.
- Signer
- A licensed clinician who decides on the draft. Identified on the record by role, licence state and a registry number checked when they sign (in the U.S., the NPI in the CMS registry).
- Decision
- Sign, revise or decline. Nothing else counts as a decision.
- Receipt
- The public part of the record. Anyone holding the document can check it against the receipt without asking the publisher.
When a named signature is required
A named signature is required when both are true:
- The draft is about one identified person, and
- someone will rely on it to act: it goes to the person as instructions, into the medical record, to a payer, or into an order, a denial or a code.
It is not required for:
- General health information that is not about an identified person.
- Work a licensed clinician wrote themselves. Their ordinary signature already applies.
- A tool that only compares a text with its source and recommends nothing (for example, a side-by-side check of an AI summary against the original).
The rule underneath: how easily the output can be checked, and how costly it is if wrong.
| Output | For example | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| Easy to check, low cost if wrong | A letter’s formatting; a billing code checked against the published fee schedule. | The AI may act. Keep the check that catches it. |
| Easy to check, high cost if wrong | A drug dose checked against a published dosing rule. | The AI may draft. An automatic check runs, and a named signer decides. |
| Hard to check, low cost if wrong | General health information that is not about one person. | The AI may write it. Label it as AI-written and correct it when it is wrong. |
| Hard to check, high cost if wrong | A letter of medical necessity; a clinical summary someone will act on. | A named signature is required. This is what the Standard covers. |
Why the signer stays: Stephen Wolfram calls what AI found “essentially a wild horse.” It is useful most of the time, and no one can prove in advance what it will do. So where the answer has to be right every time, the check sits outside the AI, and the person who answers for it is named. (Stephen Wolfram, interviewed on Digital Disruption.)
Prescriptions
An AI tool can name a medicine. It cannot prescribe one. In the U.S. a pharmacy dispenses a prescription-only drug only on a licensed prescriber’s order (21 U.S.C. 353(b)), and a controlled substance also needs the prescriber’s DEA registration (21 U.S.C. 822). The point of that step is not knowing the drug’s name. It is that a named person answers for the decision.
- A suggestion is a draft
- An AI suggestion of a medicine for one person is a draft. It is never shown as a prescription, and nothing is sent to a pharmacy until a prescriber decides.
- What the tool may say
- What a medicine is for, the usual options, whether a generic exists, and what to ask or bring to the visit. Label it as AI-written.
- What the prescriber adds
- The facts the tool does not have: the person’s other medicines, kidney and liver function, pregnancy, allergies and history. And the call that this needs an exam, not a prescription.
- Decline is a full decision
- A prescriber who would not prescribe declines, and the record says why (R3). A tool that suggests freely is the reason this step exists.
- Match the gate to the medicine
- Use the grid above. Where the law already lets a pharmacist prescribe or puts a medicine on the shelf, this Standard adds no signer the law does not require.
- A fee never buys a prescription
- Paying for an AI answer is not a review. If a prescriber is paid per review, R5 applies: the same amount whether they sign, revise or decline.
The gate has been moving toward the patient where the risk allows it: in 2023 the FDA approved naloxone nasal spray and a daily birth-control pill for sale without a prescription, and in 2022 it let state-licensed pharmacists prescribe Paxlovid.
What a signature means
By signing, revising or declining, the signer states:
- I read the draft and the source it relied on, not only the draft.
- I agree with it as written; or I revised it and agree with my revision; or I declined it.
- I am licensed in the state where the person is, and this work is within my scope of practice.
- I made this decision myself. The drafting system did not make it and cannot make it for me.
Until that decision exists, the work is a draft. It is never presented as signed before then.
Requirements
- R1Draft until decided. Until a signer decides, the work is labelled a draft and is not delivered, filed or sent as final.
- R2The checker is not the actor. The system that drafted the work does not decide on it. No second model signs in the signer’s place, and no one signs on the signer’s behalf.
- R3Three decisions, equal weight. Sign, revise and decline are each recorded with a short written reason. A decline is recorded as completely as a signature.
- R4Fail closed. If no qualified signer is available, the work waits or is declined. No timeout or default ships a draft.
- R5The decision is not paid by outcome. If the signer is paid per review, the amount is the same whether they sign, revise or decline.
- R6The record. Every decision produces the record described below, at the time of the decision.
- R7A public receipt. A third party can check that a document matches its receipt without the publisher’s help. The receipt carries no health information, and nothing identifying the person goes into a URL.
- R8Corrections are new records. A recorded decision is never edited. A correction is a new record that points to the one it corrects, so every change stays visible (tamper-evident).
- R9The human step stays. The AI never removes the human step. It moves the junior human from doing the first draft to checking it. When a trainee or junior clinician checks a draft before the signer decides, the record names that check by role, and the signer still decides.
How the decision is recorded
- Document hash
- The SHA-256 of the exact document relied on: the version signed, the revised version, or the declined draft.
- Source hash (when there is one)
- The SHA-256 of the source the signer read alongside the draft.
- Drafting model and version
- Which model or software drafted it, and its version, as reported by the drafting system.
- Decision and reason
- Signed, revised or declined, with the written reason.
- Checker (when there is one)
- The role of a person who checked the draft before the signer decided (for example, resident or nurse). A check is not a decision.
- Signer
- Role (for example, reviewing physician), licence state, and the registry number checked at signing. The public receipt shows role and licence state.
- Time
- When the decision was made, in UTC.
- Signature over the record
- A digital signature over these fields, with the public key published where anyone can find it, so the receipt can be checked offline.
On this site the receipt format runs on sample documents only: sign a sample and check it. There is no production review here yet.
What the signer is owed
A signature can only answer for what the signer controls. The parties who control the rest owe the signer this:
- From whoever builds the drafting system. Its intended use, its known limits and how often it adds findings the source does not support, stated in writing before it is used.
- From whoever deploys it. A test of the system in the workflow where it will be used, not only its headline accuracy, and the source shown next to every draft.
- For the signer. Time to read the source, and the right to decline, revise or strike any single claim in a draft without penalty from the organisation.
Responsibility here follows authority and control, the approach in the American Medical Association’s October 2026 issue brief on clinical AI liability. This Standard does not change any law.
For buyers, now that certification no longer asks
Until now, certified health IT had to show the people using a predictive AI tool where it came from, how it was tested and how its risks were managed (the HTI-1 “source attributes”). HHS’s HTI-5 final rule removes that requirement from certification, effective December 28, 2026 (91 FR 67916; 45 CFR 170.315(b)(11)(iv)–(vi)). The vendor no longer has to volunteer those answers, so the organisation putting the tool into care has to ask for them. Ask for five things in writing before go-live: the intended use and known limits; how often the tool adds findings its source does not support, measured in your own workflow; the model and version on every output it produces; who decides on each output, by role and licence, and what happens when no one is available; and a record of each decision that someone outside the vendor can check. The duty not to discriminate through patient-care decision support tools under Section 1557 (45 CFR 92.210) is unchanged by HTI-5. The requirements above are one way to write those asks into a contract.
What this Standard does not do
- It is not a clearance, a certification or legal advice, and following it does not make a product a regulated device or keep it from being one.
- It does not make a draft correct. A signer can miss an error; the signature makes the decision owned, not error-free.
- It does not replace clinical judgment, existing safety checks, or any law or payer rule that asks for more.
- It does not decide who pays for review.
Using the Standard
Published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. Copy it, adapt it and build it into policy, contracts or procurement; credit it and say what you changed. Cite it as: Named-Signer Standard, Version 1.1, 2026-11-15. harnesshealth.ai/standard. Suggestions: contact.
Credit: the outline of this Standard (a one-sentence definition, terms, numbered requirements, what it does not do, a version and a dated changelog) is adapted from the Cirtiq Standard, Version 1.0, September 2026, licensed CC BY 4.0. Changes: a different subject (a named human signer of AI-drafted clinical work, not independent order verification) and our own wording throughout. Cirtiq does not endorse this Standard.
Changelog
| Version | Date | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | 2026-11-03 | First version. |
| 1.1 | 2026-11-15 | Added "Prescriptions": an AI suggestion of a medicine is a draft; the gate matches the medicine; a fee never buys a prescription. |
Each new version gets a number, a date and a line here. The text of an earlier version is not edited in place.